Gluten Free/Dairy Free/Vegan/Sugar Free options are available in most flavors.
Call us and we will make you a yummy pie that you can eat!
Note: allergy-friendly/vegan whole pies are $3.00 extra & sugar free pies are $5.00 extra.
9" Whole Pies
Browned Butter Pecan
Gooey and chock full of pecan buttery goodness
$37.00
Apple Crumble
Loaded with spiced apples with an oatmeal crumb top, also available with a double-crusted top
$37.00
Key Lime
Tangy lime filling made with fresh lime juice and zest in a graham cracker crust & topped with fresh whipped cream & zest
$37.00
Erin's Peanut Butter Dream
Peanut butter cream cheese filling in an Oreo crust & topped melted chocolate and peanut butter cups
$37.00
Triple Berry
A melody of red raspberries, sweet strawberries, and plump blueberries with a crumb top. Also available with a double-crusted top.
$37.00
Sweet-tart Cherry
A mix of plump sweet cherries and tart cherries.
$37.00
Banana Cream
Perfectly ripe bananas layered between creamy banana pudding & topped with fresh whipped cream
$37.00
Chocolate Cream
Rich chocolate pudding made with bittersweet chocolate in an Oreo crust & topped with fresh whipped cream
$37.00
Coconut Cream
Thick coconut custard filling in a buttery crust & topped with fresh whipped cream and toasted coconut flakes
​
$37.00
Butterscotch
Creamy butterscotch pudding made with butter and brown sugar, in a flaky crust & topped with fresh whipped cream
$37.00
Palisade Peach
Fresh sliced Palisade peaches with a crumb top (Seasonal)
$37.00
Strawberry Rhubarb
Tangy pieces of rhubarb mixed with juicy sweet strawberries. A popular seasonal delight. (Seasonal April-October)
$37.00
Additional Flavors (not shown above) : Blueberry Lemon, Kahlua Fudge Brownie, Mocha Cream, Chocolate Chess, Mississippi Mud, Shoofly, Rhubarb, S'more, Grasshopper, Mincemeat, Cookies & Cream, Lemon Cream, Mimosa, Chocolate Stout, and many more!
Hand Pies
Hand pies are currently unavailable
Varieties include: Blueberry, Cherry, and Apple